Thursday, February 25, 2010

How Cartoonists See Themselves

For all the crap I give other people, I'm a pretty lousy artist. I'm trying to remedy some gaps in my artistic skill set by taking a class over at SFAI on drawing the head and the hands. This has led to some not entirely successful attempts at self-portraiture, and I got to thinking about how cartoonists represent themselves. Cartooning is, of course, representational, and it's often less about capturing what a person actually looks like than about capturing some basic essence of the individual. So let's take a look at some of the cartoonists gracing my RSS reader and their cartoon alter egos:


Adam Cadwell:

Box Brown (Okay, this is a cheat, since it's actually Ben, a character from Bellen! But Brown tends to treat Ben as an alter ego, and renders himself the same way in his book.):


Dylan Meconis:

Erika Moen:

James Kochalka:

Jeff Schuetze:

Jeffrey Brown:


Jeffrey Rowland:


Jeph Jacques:


Joel Watson:


Julia Wertz:


Kate Beaton and her Younger Self:


Lucy Knisley:


Marc Ellerby:


Meredith Gran (Note that the quickie self portrait was done back when she had dreadlocks.):


R Stevens:


Rachel Nabors:


Randy Milholland:


Rene Engstrom:

39 comments:

Walter Ostlie said...

Great Post.

Sarah McIntyre said...

Too funny!

Box Brown said...

That is awesome! I love it!

Anonymous said...

KC Green:
http://i50.tinypic.com/1673zut.jpg

Danny said...

Do you have comparison shots for Mitch Clem?

Lucas said...

Missing Mike Krahulik and Jerry Holkins from Penny Arcade:

http://imgur.com/Y7POY

Anonymous said...

Mitch Clem:
http://i49.tinypic.com/116m6ao.jpg

Anonymous said...

John Allison:
http://i46.tinypic.com/23h8t4z.jpg

Anonymous said...

Ramon Perez & Rob Coughler:
http://i50.tinypic.com/25s1zev.jpg

Anonymous said...

Thomas P. Reidy aka 'Goatboy'
http://imgur.com/TnSKW.png

Anonymous said...

Dorothy Gambrell ("Cat and Girl"):
http://i47.tinypic.com/16bakie.jpg

Anonymous said...

Chris Onstad:
http://i49.tinypic.com/14smclk.jpg

ok guys now I'm just being a dick, I'll stop

SevenCubed said...

Aww, no love for Kelli Nelson? I mean, she hasn't done webcomics in a while, but still.

-343

Evan N. said...

Awesome, I don't have anybody I draw to look like me, well except the "Killer in the Backseat" ^_^;;;;

Moral Polarity said...

What we need here is a Randall Munroe self portrait :-D

Cadwell said...

Thanks for the link Elle, I have a nice spike in my stats today :)

root said...

heh, this is awesome.

Erika Moen said...

Haha, awesome! Thanks for including me :)

The photo of me was taken by Lori Matsumoto, who is a really great photographer and has taken portraits of SO MANY cartoonists. I really encourage people to check out her work!

Joel Watson said...

This was a lot of fun. Thanks for including me.

Anonymous said...

Dorothy Gambrell is a hard woman to find a real picture of on the internet. Out of curiosity wife and I have been looking, though maybe not that hard. Mr. Chen is easier to find.

I'm trying to make the creepiest comment, I guess.

Ray Radlein said...

I have photos of Jennie (The Devil's Panties) Breeden if you want any for comparison to her self-drawings in her autobiographical comics.

Marc Ellerby said...

My cartoon self is never as happy as when it's eating.

Thanks for including me, Elle.

Sky said...

so awesome! I read a lot of these comics but I've never seen pictures of the cartoonists.

jefbot said...

great post, elle! thanks for including me with this awesome group. even bigger thanks for using one of my headshots instead of a drunk twitpic.

Rosscott said...

I'll throw my hat into this ring. I'm responsible for http://www.systemcomic.com/ and yet I here's the comparison: http://twitpic.com/169q45

Erika Moen said...

I found this... repeat? of your blog post over here: http://www.uniquescoop.com/2010/03/how-cartoonists-see-themselves.html

Is that kosher?

Chris said...

I'd love to see one for Randall from XKCD. ;)

James said...

no Karl Kerschl?

Rob said...

Who the heck are all these lame cartoonists? I don't recognize a single comic except penny arcade. And all the ugly chicks tend to draw themselves like some kinda hottie ... yeah right, delusional.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://datingaviv.blogspot.com/]הכרויות[/url]
[url=http://datingaviv.blogspot.com/]דייט[/url]
[url=http://datingaviv.blogspot.com/]היכרויות[/url]

Anonymous said...

Hey, something is wrong with your site in Opera, you should check into it.

Anonymous said...

I’ve recently started a blog, the information you provide on this site has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work.

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Proextender scam
Vimax extender

Anonymous said...

Maybe I`ll be Captain Obvious, but... it's only few days to New Year last, so let's be happy!
Hoho3ho!)

Anonymous said...

Happy New Year[url=http://nfksghjskf.com/],[/url] everyone! :)

5 Good Books for Teenage Girls said...

Hilarious stylizations!

Most Popular Books said...

Rowland got a point...

Most Popular Books on Tumblr said...

Stevens portrayed himself as a true geek, I like that.